Reviews
Part of A hot sauce production budget in three blocks, worked through
A retailer checklist for stocking hot sauce: terms, compliance and shelf sales
A retail checklist for stocking hot sauce: how to build landed cost, choose a supply route, check a maker's FDA filings and terms, and judge weekly sales.
This is a retail checklist for stocking hot sauce from independent makers: what to ask about hot sauce production and supply before the first order, how to work out what a bottle really costs you, and how to judge the line once it is on the shelf. Every line of the checklist is a document or a number to get from the maker in writing before the first case is ordered.
What to take away
- Landed cost, not invoice cost, decides your margin. Freight and breakage belong in the number.
- Compliance comes in writingFDA facility registration, the acidified foods filing, allergen labelling and either Nutrition Facts or the maker's exemption notice.
- Direct from maker and through a distributor are different businesses. Price them separately.
- Set a velocity target before the first order and write the review date next to it.
- Hot sauce is a high interest, low frequency purchase. Plan for trial, not for weekly repeat.
Work out landed cost first
Take the case price, add inbound freight per case, add an allowance for breakage, and divide by units. Written out: landed cost per bottle = (case price + freight per case + breakage allowance per case) ÷ bottles per case. That number is what the product actually cost you standing on your shelf. Watch a low case price where the buyer pays freight from three states away. It can easily cost more than a distributor line that looked dearer on paper.
A worked example, in round numbers of whatever currency you buy in: a case of 12 bottles at 48, with 6 of inbound freight and an allowance of 2 for breakage, lands at (48 + 6 + 2) ÷ 12 = 4.67 a bottle. The invoice said 4.00. The 0.67 difference is the freight and breakage that a margin calculated on the invoice never sees.
How to work out landed cost
- Take the case price
- Add inbound freight per case
- Add an allowance for breakage
- Divide by units
Set retail from landed cost and target margin. Check the result against comparable products in your store. If the price you need is well outside the shelf, the problem is the supply route, not the product.
Two sauces at very different wholesale prices are rarely the same product. Mostly, what actually changes as a hot sauce moves up the tiers is the form of the chilli and the size of the run.
Direct or through a wholesaler
Both routes are normal and solve different problems. USDA's overview of food wholesaling describes the main groups: merchant wholesalers who buy and resell, manufacturers' sales branches and offices, and agents and brokers who facilitate transactions on commission without taking ownership.
Direct vs wholesaler vs broker
Direct from maker
- Advantage
- Better margin
- Cost
- You carry freight
- Risk
- You carry risk
Merchant wholesaler
- Advantage
- One invoice
- Cost
- Lower margin
- Risk
- Wholesaler carries
Broker or agent
- Advantage
- Access to lines
- Cost
- Commission in price
- Risk
- No ownership
Knowing which you deal with tells you who carries the inventory risk. You also learn who to call when a delivery fails.
Advantage
- Direct from maker
- Better margin, closer relationship
- Merchant wholesaler
- One invoice, reliable delivery
- Broker or agent
- Access to lines you cannot reach
Cost
- Direct from maker
- You carry freight, admin and risk
- Merchant wholesaler
- Lower margin
- Broker or agent
- Commission sits in the price
The checklist before you commit
- Case pack, minimum order and price breaks in writing, for example the case count at which the unit price steps down.
- Payment terms in writingnet days from invoice, or prepayment on a first order, and whether an early-payment discount applies.
- Who pays freight, and at what order value it becomes free, and whether the price is quoted delivered or ex works, with freight on you.
- Breakage policy, in writing, with a claims window.
- Date coding and remaining shelf life on delivery, stated as a minimum number of months left when the case arrives.
- Lead time in the worst month, not the best.
- Whether the maker sells to your competitors nearby, and on what terms.
- Product liability insurance, with your business named where you require it.
- For an acidified sauce, the maker's FDA registration and filed scheduled process. Under FDA's acidified foods rule, a commercial processor registers on Form FDA 2541, giving among other things its processing method in terms of acidity and pH control, and processes each food in conformity with the scheduled processes it has filed. The acidified foods rules also require the process to run under the supervision of someone who has completed an FDA-approved course, usually called Better Process Control School; ask for the certificate.
- The maker's FDA food facility registration, current for this cycle. Facilities that manufacture, process, pack or hold food for consumption in the United States must register with FDA under section 415 of the FD&C Act, and since FSMA they must renew those registrations every other year; FDA can suspend a registration when a facility's food has a reasonable probability of causing serious adverse health consequences.
- A label that declares any of the nine major food allergensmilk, eggs, fish, Crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans and sesame. The Food Allergen Labeling and Consumer Protection Act of 2004 (FALCPA) is the law behind that list.
- Your own side of itthe retail food permit or registration your state or local health department requires for the shop.
- Nutrition Facts on the bottle, or the exemption that covers it. Packaged foods must bear nutrition labeling unless they qualify for an exemption. The small business nutrition labeling exemption for low-volume products applies when the maker employs fewer than an average of 100 full-time equivalent employees and sells fewer than 100,000 units of that product in the United States in a 12-month period, and the maker must file a notice with FDA every year. Ask for a copy of that notice if the bottle carries no panel.
Those answers place a supplier in one of a few operating types, each with its own cost shape and its own breaking point. That tells you whether a sudden reorder is something they can absorb.
Setting a velocity target
Decide, before the first case arrives, how many units a week justify the space. A specialty hot sauce that moves two units a week at a strong margin may be worth more than a national brand at ten units on a thin one. That holds only if you have done the arithmetic rather than the feeling. With the landed cost above, a bottle sold at 7.99 earns 3.32; two a week is 6.64 a week from that facing. A national brand that earns 0.60 a bottle needs eleven a week to match it.
Season matters in this category more than in most. Hot sauce sells into gifting at the end of the year and into grilling in the summer. A line judged on its worst eight weeks will be dropped unfairly.
Set a written trial window that covers at least one peak, with a review date. Record weekly units rather than a single total, per facing if the line has more than one. Then you can see whether the product is building or being bought once by curious customers who never return.
Growing a specialty range is a business decision like any other. The Small Business Administration's grow your business material covers the funding, market research and expansion questions that come with holding more inventory.
For the supply side view of why these prices look the way they do, see the hot sauce cost guide. For the general stocking questions that apply across the category, see the condiment stocking checklist.
